A 32 minute read
stuffed-dog-stethoscope
February 21, 2020

Both the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) and Medicaid play critical roles in ensuring that children across the U.S. are receiving healthcare coverage regardless of their family’s financial status.  

But, in some states there is no difference between the two programs in terms of benefits or eligibility requirements due to flexibilities afforded to a state in designing its policy — so, what distinguishes CHIP from Medicaid? 

How is CHIP funded? 

CHIP is funded jointly at the federal and state levels of legislature through a formula based on the Medicaid Federal Medical Assistance Percentage (FMAP). As additional incentive for states to expand their coverage programs for children, Congress enhanced the federal matching rate for CHIP, which is generally about 23 percent higher than the Medicaid rate — averaging 93 percent nationally. 

Because CHIP is a capped program, each state is provided an annual CHIP allotment. Every fiscal year, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) determines their share of program funding for that year. States must provide matching funds to get their federal funding allotment. 

CHIP eligibility for children

Chip eligibility is, ultimately, decided on a state-to-state basis, but the majority of states set the threshold at 200 percent of the federal poverty level or more for children. CHIP can also support pregnant women under more variable circumstances.  

Although CHIP covers more children than Medicaid, its coverage options are more limited as well. 

Medicaid eligibility for children 

Children from families earning 133 percent or less of the federal poverty level per year are eligible for Medicaid. Up until 2010, with the passing of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), child eligibility was also based on age; the older a child was, the less likely they were to qualify. The ACA made it so that income eligibility was standard for children between 6 and 19 years old. 

Benefits: CHIP vs. Medicaid 

There are larger differences between CHIP and Medicaid in terms of required benefits.

While they may vary state to state, Medicaid services must provide certain minimum mandatory services: 

  • Children’s immunizations 
  • Prenatal care 
  • Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnostic and Treatment (EPSDT) services for children 
  • Physician services 
  • Hospital care (inpatient and outpatient) 

Whereas CHIP  while still varying state to state  must provide a package of services equivalent to at least those given to the policy-designing state’s employees and need not match all the services covered by that state’s Medicaid program. 

The minimum requirements of CHIP coverage include: 

  • Routine check-ups 
  • Immunizations 
  • Doctor visits 
  • Prescriptions 
  • Dental and vision care 
  • Inpatient and outpatient hospital care 
  • Laboratory and X-ray services 
  • Emergency services 

CHIP vs. Medicaid enrollment rates 

All states are required to provide data to CMS on a range of indicators related to key application, eligibility, and enrollment processes with the Medicaid and CHIP processes. Below is a list of the 20 states with the highest amount of CHIP enrollments: 

Top 10 states with highest CHIP enrollment 

Rank 

State name 

State expanded Medicaid 

Total Medicaid enrollment 

Total CHIP enrollment 

1 

California 

Y 

10530288 

1293571 

2 

Texas 

N 

3631572 

646131 

3 

New York 

Y 

5883397 

643744 

4 

North Carolina 

N 

1495121 

258899 

5 

Illinois 

Y 

2564139 

253417 

6 

Florida 

N 

3450613 

229377 

7 

New Jersey 

Y 

1492517 

210515 

8 

Georgia 

N 

1588271 

209924 

9 

Ohio 

Y 

2444657 

206210 

10 

Pennsylvania 

Y 

2757505 

180902 

Fig 1: Data pulled from data.medicaid.gov as provided by The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Updated Jan. 1, 2019. 

The data shows that the states with the most CHIP enrollments have approximately 10 times as many Medicaid enrollments. There is also, to a lesser extent, a noticeable correlation between a higher state cost of living and CHIP enrollments. California and New York have two of the highest costs of living in the U.S. - and they both rank at the top of the list. 

CHIP use across the U.S. 

Definitive Healthcare’s Professional Services team cross-referenced official CHIP data provided via the Medicare website data from within our own platform, and the results convey some interesting insights into how CHIP is being utilized. This first chart highlights the top diagnoses for each of CHIP's two covered patient types: children and pregnant women.

Top 5 diagnoses for children under CHIP

Rank 

Patient category 

ICD-10 code 

ICD-10 code description 

Patient volume 

1 

Child 

J069 

Acute upper respiratory infection, unspecified 

28,759 

2 

Child 

J029 

Acute pharyngitis, unspecified 

25,413 

3 

Child 

R509 

Fever, unspecified 

17,292 

4 

Child 

J020 

Streptococcal pharyngitis 

13,431 

5 

Child 

R05 

Cough 

11,646 

Fig 2Insights provided by the Definitive Healthcare Professional Services team for use in this article. Based on data from Hospitals & IDNs database (2019). 

Top 5 diagnoses for pregnant women under CHIP

Rank

Patient category

ICD-10 code

ICD-10 code description

Patient volume

1 

Pregnant female 

I10 

Essential (primary) hypertension 

10,210 

2 

Pregnant female 

O80 

Encounter for full-term uncomplicated delivery 

7,172 

3 

Pregnant female 

O0993 

Supervision of high risk pregnancy, unspecified, third trimester 

6,124 

4 

Pregnant female 

O0992 

Supervision of high risk pregnancy, unspecified, second trimester 

4,680 

5 

Pregnant female 

E119 

Type 2 diabetes mellitus without complications 

4,184 

Fig 3Insights provided by the Definitive Healthcare Professional Services team for use in this article. Based on data from Hospitals & IDNs database (2019). 

All U.S. states use CHIP funds to provide coverage for children, but only 18 states also use CHIP funding to cover pregnant women — this explains the clear division in patient volume between children and pregnant women reflected in the ranking above. The number one most common diagnosis billed by child CHIP enrollees (upper respiratory infection) is almost 3 times as prevalent as the number one most common diagnosis among pregnant women (hypertension). 

Top 10 diagnoses for the top 5 CHIP active states 

Rank 

ICD-10 code 

ICD-10 code description 

Claims volume 

Patient volume 

1 

J069 

Acute upper respiratory infection, unspecified 

37,533 

27,977 

2 

J029 

Acute pharyngitis, unspecified 

35,502 

25,129 

3 

R509 

Fever, unspecified 

22,599 

17,092 

4 

R05 

Cough 

16,720 

13,273 

5 

J020 

Streptococcal pharyngitis 

17,102 

12,869 

6 

I10 

Essential (primary) hypertension 

17,586 

10,644 

7 

R109 

Unspecified abdominal pain 

12,094 

8,843 

8 

J309 

Allergic rhinitis, unspecified 

10,692 

7,382 

9 

O80 

Encounter for full-term uncomplicated delivery 

8,727 

7,378 

10 

N390 

Urinary tract infection, site not specified 

10,362 

7,317 

Fig 4Insights provided by the Definitive Healthcare Professional Services team for use in this article. Based on data from Hospitals & IDNs database (2019). Top 5 states based on CHIP data availability. 

By observing the top 10 diagnoses across the 5 most CHIP active states within our records, we again see that CHIP diagnoses among children are still the most common. Acute upper respiratory infection is still the number one highest volume diagnosis. Acute pharyngitis is a close second, but then we can see a 10,000+ claims decline to the third ranked diagnosis of fever.  

Learn more 

Looking for more information on federal healthcare effectiveness? Read our recently updated Top Hospitals by Medicaid and Medicare Payor Mix blog for hospital-specific stats and insights.  

Curious about other healthcare and analytics topics? Head over to the Definitive Blog hub to search through our extensive collection of content. 


ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Tarell Morris

An English graduate and a tech nerd — I enjoy reading, writing, and getting involved with some technical nitty-gritty and design when time and opportunity allow for it. Some favorite books of mine ...


Continue Reading